Today's Columbia Spectator includes an excellent op-ed piece by anthropology professor Rosalind Morris. "When Fair Isn't Balanced" questions Spectator's decision to publish Paula Stern's "Greatest Victory, Even in Defeat" earlier this month.
Prof. Morris observes that publishing the Stern piece, which had previously been published in five other venues, violated Spectator's own policy that all submissions must be original material. She further criticizes the paper for its willingness to publish any submitted piece without skeptical examination of the facts or consideration of the argument. "'Opinion' is not an alibi for misrepresentation," she argues.
Prof. Morris's critique is well-founded. On the same day that Stern's vitriolic attack against El-Haj appeared, and in fact on the very same page of the print edition, the Spectator editorial board wrote, in "Protecting Professors", that the "University must reaffirm that while the marketplace of ideas may expose professors to criticism, the intrusion of non-academic pressure on the tenure process is unacceptable." Of course, this is an important point, but the Spectator editorial board could itself help reduce this "intrusion of non-academic pressure" by refraining from publishing politically-driven, biased diatribes masquerading as reasoned, respected opinion.
Wednesday, November 28, 2007
Prof. Morris Questions Spec's Submission Practices
Tuesday, November 27, 2007
SDS Regional Conference This Weekend
SDS is having its Northeastern convention this weekend in Philadelphia. Events include "Towards a Collective Liberation Vision" and "Hip Hop for Palestine" as well as tons of info on organizing, working with media, and building a movement. Columbia can expect to have a more militant, articulate, and feisty left once the SDSers get back to campus.
If you want to get involved with the convention, contact Beth Blum - binahmirah@gmail.com
Friday: Screening of "Finally Got the News" at NYU
FINALLY GOT THE NEWS is a forceful, unique documentary that reveals the activities of the League of Revolutionary Black Workers inside and outside the auto factories of Detroit. Through interviews with the members of the movement, footage shot in the auto plants, and footage of leafleting and picketing actions, the film documents their efforts to build an independent black labor organization that, unlike the UAW, will respond to worker's problems, such as the assembly line speed-up and inadequate wages faced by both black and white workers in the industry.
When: Friday, November 30, 6:00 PM
Where: NYU Dept. of Sociology, Puck Bldg,
4th Floor 295 Lafayette St. NY, NY 10012
"Although most histories of the Civil Rights and Black Power movements give greater attention to [other groups]... the League [of Revolutionary Black Workers] was in many respects the most significant expression of black radical thought and activism in the 1960s. The League took the impetus for Black Power and translated it into a fighting program focusing on industrial workers."—Manning Marable, Director, Institute for Research in African-American Studies, Professor of History, Columbia UniversityIf you want educate yourself about the League of Revolutionary Black Workers but can't attend the film, check out these books: Detroit, I Do Mind Dying: A Study in Urban Revolution and Class, Race, and Worker Insurgency. Read more!
Rally to Support the Bolivarian Revolution in Venezuela
One of the most exciting recent developments in international politics has been Hugo Chavez's outspoken challenge to the neo-liberal order and the Washington Consensus imposed on Latin America. Check out an
earlier post on el participante for details and discussion of these developments.
Attend the Rally with Lucha: Meet up at the Gates (116th and B'way) at 12:15
Saturday, Dec. 1st at 1pm
Venezuelan Consulate
7 East 51th Street
(between 5th Avenue and Madison Avenue)
Take the E/V to 5th Ave or the 6 train to 51st St.
Saturday, November 24, 2007
More ICE Raids
As part of a massive round-up of undocumented workers, ostensibly targeting gang members and others involved in illegal activities, recent coverage has made it clear that these raids are more about intimidation and profiling than about stopping crimes.
The Times reports on a recent raid in Greenport, Long Island which has caused considerable controversy and community tension:Only one of the 11 men taken away that morning was suspected of a gang affiliation, according to the Southold Town police, who patrol Greenport and played the crucial role of identifying targets for the operation.
The 10 others, while accused of immigration violations, were not gang associates and had no criminal records.
Instead, they were known as good workers and family men. When they suddenly vanished into the far-flung immigration detention system, six of their employers hired lawyers to try to find and free them. Some went further, like Dan and Tina Finne, who agreed to take care of the 3-year-old American-born daughter of a Guatemalan carpenter who was swept up in the raid, if her mother was detained, too.
“This is un-American,” said Ms. Finne, 41, a Greenport native, echoing other citizens who condemned the home raids in public meetings and letters to The Suffolk Times, a weekly newspaper. “We need to do something about immigration, but not this.”
Friday, November 23, 2007
Today is Buy Nothing Day
The anarcho-environmental folks at ad-busters have been putting this together for quite a few years now. Even the New York Times has noticed this year. While the frenzied celebration of capitalist consumerism is certainly disgusting, what are the limits of this form of mobilizing people's opposition to the social costs of capitalism? Is "anti-consumption" a viable message for the left to embrace? While there is much merit in these subversive and slick campaigns, it seems important to think about the limits of such activities at the same time that we support them in their work.
While selling sex, objectifying women, and spreading commodity fetishism, MTV has rejected advertising about Buy Nothing Day. Send an email to the execs.
Check out these links:
- BND on Wikipedia.org
- BND in News
- International BND Website
- Japan BND Website
- UK BND Website
- BND Facebook Group
- BND YouTube Playlist
- BND Flickr Group
Tuesday, November 20, 2007
Community Meeting on Expansion
There will be a meeting of the Education Committee of the Local Development Corporation for West Harlem this evening.
5 PM in the Pentecostal Church on 125th and Old Broadway (between Bway and Amsterdam).
Monday, November 19, 2007
NYPD Kill Another Man in Brooklyn
Early on Saturday, 18 November, NYPD officers from Brooklyn's 75th precinct shot and killed David Kostovski, 29, as they tried to arrest him. The police officers fired two series of shots at the deceased, who was allegedly mentally ill. They first shot at him after he refused to put down the broken bottle in his hand, which they thought was a knife, and lunged out at them as they attempted arrest, "momentarily halting him." But when Mr. Kostovski raised his non-bottle-wielding arm, they pumped a second round of bullets into him, killing him.
In total, 12 shot were fired, which almost seems reasonable in comparison to the 20 shots fired less than a week before when Brooklyn NYPD officers shot and killed a black man wielding a hairbrush during an attempted arrest. This time the officers did not even believe that their "suspect" had a gun.
"These cops got to stop this," Brooklyn resident Shirley Smith says in a Times interview. "They’re shooting people like crazy."
Her sentiments cannot be echoed strongly enough.
Monday, 20 November: Sundaes on Mondays
Join ROOTEd for a discussion on class priviledge and of course, ice cream.
IRC, 9 pm.
Sponsored by Respecting Ourselves and Others Through Education (ROOTEd).
Sunday, November 18, 2007
POSTPONED - POSTPONED: Monday 19 November: Columbia Solidarity Day Of Silence
[Sometime next week????] students supporting reform in the core curriculum, administrative support, ethnic studies, and Manhattanville expansion will be silent as a form of personal protest to the lack of response by the administration. In addition to this personal act of support, come to the silent demonstration on Low Steps at 11:00 am. Wear black as a sign of solidarity.
To participate in the day of silence, come to the Steps at 11am on Monday, and refrain from conversation until noon on Tuesday, 20 November.
Sponsored by Columbia Solidarity.
Tuesday, 20 November: Latinas & Body Image
Come engage in an activity to help us come up with an image of the "ideal latina" and discuss what it means to look "latina".
Does your family ever tell you what you should look like?
What is "just right"?
Do you tell your girlfriend that she is eating too much?
Join las Hermanas of Latinas Promoviendo Comunidad/ Lambda Pi Chi Sorority, Inc. as we discuss these issues and more.
Lerner, Board Room 502, 6:45 pm.
Sponsored by Latinas Promoviedo Comunidad / Lambda Pi Chi
The Labor Movement
Labor Notes reports on growing rank and file discontent with recent concessions made by the the UAW leadership.
Writers:
Large-scale actions will resume on Tuesday, November 20th at Sony Plaza, 56th and Madison from 10:00 a.m. - 2:00 p.m.
Call Or Write These Media Executives And Tell Them:
Give The Writers A Fair Share Of The Billions Your Company Makes From The Content They Create. I Want My Favorite Shows Back Soon!
| Anne Sweeney | President,
| The Walt Disney Company, 500 S. Buena Vista Street, Burbank, CA 91521-4581
| 818-560-1000
|
| Kevin Reilly | President, | Fox Broadcasting, 10201 West Pico Boulevard, Los Angeles, CA 90064-2606
| 310-369-1000 |
| Bruce Rosenblum | President, | Warner Bros. Studios, 3400 Riverside Drive, Burbank, CA 91505
| 818-954-6000 |
| Philippe Dauman | President/CEO, | 1515 Broadway, New York, NY 10036-5794
| 212-258-6000 |
| Leslie Moonves | President/CEO, | CBS, 51 West 52nd Street, New York, NY 10019-6101
| 212-975-4545 |
| Jeff Zucker | President/CEO, | NBC Universal, 100 Universal City Plaza, Universal City, CA 91608-1002 | 212-664-4444 |
Check www.strikepoints.com and www.unitedhollywood.com for the latest action steps and information.
The writers of your favorite movies and TV shows need your help! In addition to calling the companies above, add your name to the growing list of supporters and be ready to answer the call when action is needed.
Check out why you should support the workers who create television:Police Kill a Man in Brooklyn
On Monday, 12 November, Khiel Coppin, an 18 year old black man, was shot and killed by five NYPD police officers responding to a domestic dispute call placed by Coppin's mother. The police officers, who claim to have believed that Coppin was armed, fired twenty shots at him, eight of which hit and killed him. No gun was found on his body, but rather a black hairbrush.
The New York Times does not seem to think that it is relevant that Khiel Coppin was black. Examine its coverage, here and here. In the first article, Coppin's racial identity is never mentioned; and it is only at the end of the second article that the Times mentions that he is black, in a comparison to the shooting of Sean Bell last year.
The implication, of course, is that Coppin's being a black man is irrelevant information that does not need to be explicitly acknowledged or emphasized. Readers, in looking at the accompanying pictures, can figure out for themselves that he was black.
Playing down Coppin's black identity is troubling and odd. Perhaps the Times believes, because the five officers who shot him were not all white, that his race does not matter. Such logic is highly questionable, as City Councilman Charles Barron points out: "I don't care whether they are black, Latino, or white, when they join the force most of them turn blue," he said. "When you turn blue, you police the white community one way and you police the black community another way."
Saturday, November 17, 2007
Hunger Strike
It's all over folks, but the struggle continues. Specifically, students have organized a day of silence on Monday to demonstrate how Columbia has silenced and ignored both students and residents in its plans to expand into West Harlem. The action starts on Monday at 11 am on the steps of Low. Check out the flyer.
In the next issue of el participante we hope to collect several takes on the strike reflecting the strengths, weaknesses, achievements, and failures of what has been one of the most remarkable student movements in Columbia's recent history. If you have an idea that you'd like to see published in next month's el participante, email us at editors.el.participante@gmail.com
Friday, November 16, 2007
New York Times on Chavez and Socialism
As a referendum on constitutional changes and massive new social programs nears, the New York Times reports on the widespread support for Chavez among poor and working people, the concern and uncertainty of elites, and the uniqueness of Venezuela's approach to socialism.
What is the potential, the danger, and the significance of events in Venezuela - much remains uncertain. Will capitalist powers stand by as Chavez carries out his experiment? Allende certainly did not succeed in Chile, but the logic of the Cold War cannot be as easily deployed to destroy and disrupt what is happening in Venezuela. Perhaps the ties to Iran will allow a coup within the framework of the "war on terrorism."
Immigration Week: Friday, 16 November
Fund-raising Party for
Victims of Hurricane Noel
Hurricane Noel triggered flooding and landslides that
killed at least 64 people in the Dominican Republic and
Haiti this past week. Some 37,500 people were forced
from their homes. In Mexico, nearly half a million people
have been made homeless across the southeastern state
of Tabasco. Funds raised from the party will go to the
Red Cross’ relief fund in Haiti, the Dominican Republic,
and Mexico. 10:30 pm, C555 Lerner
Thursday, November 15, 2007
Rally Today at Noon!
Press Release from the Student Strikers
Sundial at Columbia University
College Walk, W. 116th St., between Broadway and Amsterdam
Tonight, despite the administration briefly declaring negotiations closed, the coalition of students and faculty at Columbia University involved with a hunger strike won a set of concessions from the administration regarding curricular and administrative reform. The strike will continue until administrators and student negotiators reach agreement on revisions to Columbia's plan to expand into West Harlem.
The administration has committed, subject to approval by the Task Force on Undergraduate Education, to raising fifty million dollars in order to staff a seminar format for the non-Western portion of the Core Curriculum. Currently, every other Humanities requirement in the Core is taught in capped seminar format. Administrators will also put out a call for proposals from faculty for new courses for the Core Curriculum
The administration has agreed to raise funds for the expansion of the Office of Multicultural Affairs, to the extent recommended by a review by a consultant firm. Administrators offered a blueprint for student involvement in the academic review committee for the Center for the Study of Ethnicity and Race, which will decide the future of the Center. Finally, administrators guaranteed that there will be no disciplinary action brought against any hunger striker.
In the late afternoon, administrators issued a demand that two student hunger strikers end their eight day demonstration, or be forced on medical leave for the remainder of the semester. Administrators further threatened that if strikers did not accept a specific set of proposals offered at 7pm, the administration would walk out of negotiations.
While these threats hung in the air, at 9pm, approximately two hundred students gathered for a previously scheduled vigil. Upon hearing the administration's position, students spontaneously formed a rally and marched across campus, gathering in front of Hamilton Hall, where administrators were convened. Hamilton Hall has been the location of student sit-ins several times in the last decades. At this point, the administration resumed negotiations.
Outstanding demands of the coalition of students and faculty include a critical revision of Columbia's plan for expansion into West Harlem. A meeting is scheduled for Thursday to negotiate specific points of compromise brought forth by students.
A larger rally is scheduled for Thursday at noon, to coincide with a luncheon between administrators and major donors to the university.
Read more!Immigration Week: Thursday November 15th Movie Screening with CSER
Thursday, 15 November:
Movie Screening: Wetback (2004)
In conjunction with the Institute for Latin Ameri-
can Studies and the Center for the Study of Ethnicity
and Race, Lucha is screening “Wetback,” director Arturo
Perez Torres’s heartbreaking tale of Central American
border crossers. A discussion with Torres will follow the
screening. 207 Warren Hall, 7-10pm.
For those who missed the movie...
Wednesday, November 14, 2007
Immigration Week, Wednesday November 14th
Join us for a call-in on Congress to demand that the
Democratic leadership push for the DREAM Act to be
considered immediately! Low Plaza, 12-4 pm.
================================
Panel on Immigration Raids:
How the US Terrorizes Immigrant
Communities
A panel of representatives from the Puerto Rican
Legal Defense and Education Fund and the Workplace
Project will discuss the recent series of immigration
raids on Long Island, which resulted in the detainment
of 187 people. 411 Kent, 8pm.
Tuesday, November 13, 2007
Immigration Week, Tuesday November 13: School of the Americas: State Sponsor of Terrorism and Torture
Claudia De La Cruz--Director of the Dominican
Women’s Youth Development Center, Pastor at la Igle-
sia San Romero de Las Americas, Latin American Studies
Professor at CUNY John Jay, Masters candidate at the
Columbia School of Social Work, and an a long time ac-
tivist for immigrant rights, women’s rights and social jus-
tice--will speak about the US Army School of Americas
(SOA). Based in Fort Benning, Georgia, SOA trains Latin
American security personnel in combat, counter insur-
gency, and counter-narcotics. SOA graduates are respon-
sible for some of the worst human rights abuses in Latin
America, including the massacre of Las Ojas. Because
of its notorious reputation, the school was renamed the
Western Hemisphere Institute for Security and Coopera-
tion (WHINSEC) in 2001.
As part of her presentation, Professor La Cruz will air
a documentary about SOA’s role in US foreign policy in
Latin America. 301 Fayerwether, 8pm.
Also Today:
Rally at the Sundial with CCAW
No More $$ For War Profiteers!
Columbia has $4 million invested
in war profi teers Lockheed Martin,
General Dynamics and Raytheon.
Rally to demand that the committee
on Socially Responsible Investing at
Columbia divest from those compa-
nies that supply munitions for the
unjust war on Iraq. Afterwards, join
the town hall meeting and let your
voice be heard. E-mail krs24@co-
lumbia.edu to speak at the meeting.
Sundial, 5pm.
